“The value of an idea lies in the using of it.” – Thomas Alva Edison
“In my experience, there’s no such thing as luck.” – Ben Kenobi
Happy Friday the Thirteenth and happy Picture Book Idea Month! My name is Ryan Hipp, I am an author-illustrator of picture books and today’s guest writer for Tara’s blog.
Black cats crossing your path, 13’s abounding, broken mirrors shattering, and walking under ladders are dangerous portents. To an author, these omens cannot compare to the terror of writer’s block! Today I will present the two most important words in picture book publishing: Ideas and luck…and I’ll share why I feel both of those words are meaningless superstitions.
Really.
Let’s start with IDEAS.
When people enjoy a book, they often say, “what a great idea.” As someone who makes books for kids, I often get asked, “where do you get your ideas?”
I answer, “Finding ideas is not the challenge for me. The challenge is knowing what idea is the one to build on.” (Tara’s note: see the PiBoIdMo grand prize announcement.)
I don’t know why I have come to this conclusion, but I never understood why so many people focus on the “idea” as being so critical to a successful book. I have exactly 47 great ideas and even more acceptably average ones; more than enough ideas to feed my family for the next 60 years. Unfortunately, before you can spend ideas, you have to invest them––and the exchange rate in the publishing world is blood, sweat, and tears.
Sometimes people want to share with me that they also, “have a great idea for a book.”
Similarly, I am not impressed with people with ideas. Never. Ideas are cheap. They come too easily to all of us. The truth is, there is not a shortage on ideas. Everyone has ideas. Everyone. I am more impressed with something more rare and valuable than an idea: perseverance, practice, dedication, commitment, hard work, and patience. The best idea in the world is a moot point until you start climbing that mountain and joining the other hard workers on the summit.
I don’t want to discount the importance of ideas. Every good book starts with a good idea; but they are just building blocks, not a castle. So my advice is to keep dreaming, and keep generating ideas; but don’t forget the more important step: bring those ideas to life.
Now let’s move on to LUCK.
“Luck is simply how something is explained after it has happened. It isn’t real,” says editor Tim Travaglini.
Your car breaking down is not bad luck. Finding a silver dollar on the ground is not good luck. These events are simply the eventuality of your radiator overheating and someone else having a hole in their pocket. It is that simple. Things happen.
I sometimes hear authors and illustrators humbly say, “I was in the right place at the right time,” when answering questions about their “good luck” in the world of publishing. Needless to say, talent and work may have played a more significant part. To get a picture book deal, good luck is not real. Bad luck is not real. Perseverance, practice, dedication, commitment, hard work, and patience are real.
So on this day filled with luck in this month filled with ideas, I ask of you: keep building, keep working, and have an unlucky Friday the Thirteenth!
Ryan Hipp is a published author-illustrator of picture books who lives in Grand Rapids, MI. His style is whimsical and obtainable for all ages. Another big part of Ryan’s career is giving presentations: Ryan has developed seminars for teachers, parents, and students––to get kids excited about creativity and to help adults facilitate creativity in kids, too.
(Ryan created the PiBoIdMo logos, so let’s hear a Hipp-Hipp Hooray!)
















18 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 13, 2009 at 9:55 am
Jewel
I had not even thought of today as an unlucky day until I read your post. LOL
“Finding ideas is not the challenge for me. The challenge is knowing what idea is the one to build on.” is indeed a challenge for most writers. I am curious, what do you look for in an idea that pricks your imagination to the point of becoming a story or illustration?
Thank you so much for the great logo!
November 13, 2009 at 10:11 am
hipphop
Hi Jewel!
Thanks for asking.
For me, the idea has to be something I’ve never heard or seen someone do before, and it has to have some sort of funny or ironic edge. That’s what makes it special.
At the risk of spilling the beans of one of my ideas, here’s an example:
Pirates have been done to death. Vampires are hot in the media right now. Neither of them are very inventive or special. In fact, I snore whenever I see someone doing either…but VAMPIRATES is funny, and I don’t think anyone has tried it yet (I don’t think).
Ryan
November 13, 2009 at 9:22 pm
Jewel
Thank you for your reply Ryan.
I think I have been writing a lot of the same ol stuff list. I am changing my perspective.
A vampirate is funny. How about a barking parrot? Would that tickle your funny bone?
Again thank you for your time.
November 14, 2009 at 10:53 am
hiphop
Jewel,
…Hmmm. A barking parrot? Maybe. But let’s take another look.
This is actually a good follow-up example of how my brain figures out what a good idea is to work from:
I’ll show you another example of “…and it has to have some sort of funny or ironic edge…”. It also has to “make sense” in my mind. Its more a feeling.
Once we have “vampirate” as a starting point, everything building on after that has to make sense for it to “feel right”.
So maybe a vampirate doesn’t have a parrot. Maybe he has a little brown bat named “Polly”. That seems more an appropriate build on the idea, huh?
Ryan
November 14, 2009 at 2:56 pm
Jewel
Yup, makes a great fit. Thanks so much Ryan.
November 13, 2009 at 11:35 am
Auntie Flamingo
Ryan
I love your advice in today’s blog entry. “Perseverance, practice, dedication, commitment, hard work, and patience” so true. I’ve looked back on some of the very first manuscripts I wrote and sent in for publication and thought, “Geez, no wonder they didn’t get published. What was I thinking?” And I realize how much I have improved on my writing and how much I have grown. With each edit and manuscript submission I get closer and closer to publication. I now have a ms in the final round for possible acceptance. If I had given up after my rejections at the beginning I wouldn’t be where I am today. “Perseverance, practice, dedication, commitment, hard work, and patience” is certainly key.
Auntie Flamingo
P.S. I like your logo and have it posted on my blog.
November 13, 2009 at 11:44 am
hipphop
Thanks Auntie. 🙂
November 13, 2009 at 1:19 pm
deborah freedman
Well said, Ryan. Both ideas and luck are worthless if we don’t have the stamina to do something with them!
November 13, 2009 at 1:59 pm
hipphop
Thanks Deborah!
November 14, 2009 at 9:11 pm
Z-Dad
Great advice Ryan!
November 15, 2009 at 8:59 am
Sheri Dillard
Thanks for the great advice, Ryan! And thanks for the PiBoIdMo logo, too!
I’m curious — how do you all say that out loud? “Pee-Bow (bow like a hair bow)-Id (id as in kid)-Moe?” Or another way? How is Nano said out loud? “Nah-no?” “Nah-no-wri (long “i”)-Moe?”
November 16, 2009 at 2:03 pm
hipphop
Sheri, I never say that word aloud!
haha
I actually just say it the long way : Picture Book Idea Month.
but I would guess if you were, it would be “Pih-Bow-Id-Moe”
November 16, 2009 at 5:09 pm
tara
I said it at the picture book seminar yesterday: Pea-Bow-Id-Mow. And everyone thought I was insane. However, I think that’s a nice quality to have if you’re a picture book author.
November 15, 2009 at 11:30 am
Kelly Fineman
Hooray for Ryan (and the logo)! I have tucked aside some of his post for NEXT Sunday’s quoteskimming post. Also, I figured I’d share this tidbit from Thomas Jefferson, which, although about luck, I’m pretty sure Ryan will approve: “I’m a great believer in luck, and I find the harder I work the more I have of it.”
November 16, 2009 at 2:04 pm
hipphop
Nice one, Kelly! Thanks!
November 16, 2009 at 11:21 pm
Jewel
Ryan and Tara,
I found an example of taking something ordinary and making it extraordinarily funny by building on what makes sense. (The NY Public Library has PBs to view online.) Take a look at Robert Munch’s MUD PUDDLE at http://www.tumblebooks.com/library/asp/full_book.asp?ProductID=2999
Summary:
Whenever Jule Ann goes outside, a Mud Puddle jumps on her and gets her muddy all over. But she defeats it with cheerful ingenuity and two bars of smelly yellow soap. The kid is the hero.
November 17, 2009 at 3:09 pm
hipphop
Great example Jewel!
April 23, 2010 at 1:58 pm
Ryan Hipp’s Unlucky Day (archive) | RyanHipp.com
[…] https://taralazar.wordpress.com/2009/11/13/piboidmo-day-13/ […]