I hate air travel with children. I mean with my own children. My goal for the flight is to ensure that my toddler and Kindergartener don’t disturb the other passengers. I don’t want them whining, crying, screaming, running through the aisles or otherwise causing mayhem. I remember being a stressed-out businesswoman and being seated near a miserable child. I have empathy for the childless travelers, honestly I do.
I spend a ridiculous amount of time preparing for the trip and devising solutions for worst-case scenarios. Flight delays. Missed naps. Sudden fever. Soiled clothes. Motion sickness. I’ve got it all covered, people.
My foolproof plan involves a bag of books. I read to my children on the flight. (Oh yeah, I can’t forget the lollipops…great for easing the pressure on take-off and landing.)
However, I found out that my efforts to entertain and enlighten my children aren’t necessarily appreciated.
The older woman in front of me turned around in the middle of a story and asked, “How long do you plan on reading aloud?”
So continued a rudeness I’ve never experienced before, someone complaining about a happy, content family. She mistakenly said I had been reading for an hour when the flight had been in the air only 25 minutes, and she told me that if I was going to “read for another hour” she “wouldn’t be able to take it.”
Did you ever have one of those conversations where you wish you could say something different than what leaves your mouth?
I could let my children play bongos on the tray tables if you prefer.
A crying jag can be arranged.
We’re going to peek over the seats and force you into an endless game of peek-a-boo later.
Instead, I apologized like the polite person I am. I was sitting in the last row with a terrible jet engine din and could barely hear what I was reading. Was I a little loud? Maybe. Could she have approached the subject differently? Sure. So could the cowardly husband who decided to give a rude stare and play with his seat, knowing that we in the last row had nowhere to recline ourselves.
She finished by not making eye contact. “Well, just lower your voice.”
Hmmm. I didn’t hear “please.”

















16 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 6, 2009 at 2:22 pm
diapersanddivas
I have to say….you’re a much better person than I. I would have most def. made some snarky comment. Planning a trip to Cali in Sept. with my 1 year old and am dreading it….I’ll try to keep your experience in mind when i get those stares and looks….smile and breath, right?
July 6, 2009 at 2:31 pm
tara
I’ve been flying with my kids for almost 6 years now and this was the first uncomfortable experience we’ve had.
Pack a bag of tricks. A wrapped new toy. Heck, even an old one that’s been wrapped is still loads of fun. And you wouldn’t believe the calming, entertaining effects of a cup of ice.
And honestly, don’t spend as much time as I do worrying about 90 minutes. It’s a tiny fraction of your vacation and you’ll never see those people again. Unless, of course, they happen to be on your return flight!
If you can, ask for the bulkhead (first) row. There’s a little extra room for a toddler to stand up if they refuse to sit down. I’ve found that keeping a toddler seated is the most difficult task of the entire flight. If you can control that, you’re golden.
Have a great vacation!
July 6, 2009 at 2:46 pm
Kate Messner
Oh dear. You are a good person. I fear that lady would have caused me to read even more loudly.
Meanwhile, I have to share a different “reading on the plane” story with you. The last time we traveled, the woman in front of me was reading a picture book aloud to her kids – one about the first woman to swim the English Channel. I kept leaning forward more and more so I could hear and to see the pictures between the seats that she finally looked over her shoulder and raised her eyebrows at me.
“Sorry,” I smiled. “I was just listening, too. It’s really good.”
She happily held it a little higher so my daughter and I could see, too. If only you’d been seated near her instead!
July 6, 2009 at 4:22 pm
tara
What a nice story! Do you remember the name of the book? I’d be interested to read it, too. My daughter loves swimming.
July 6, 2009 at 8:29 pm
Jacqui
You are much calmer than I am. I would probably have stopped reading and let my toddler do his worst on her seat.
July 6, 2009 at 8:49 pm
Lizzie
GRR!
July 7, 2009 at 8:03 am
Laurie
My favorite kid airline story happened when my daughters were one and five. As a businessman came down the aisle, you could see hissigh of relief when he realized he would be sitting next to my husband and the five-year-old, not the baby and me. He was less happy when the five-year-old threw up because of turbulence.
July 7, 2009 at 10:18 am
Christy
oh wow! that is really rude of that woman! And you’re right, How much could she have really heard over the engine anyway!!!!!
People really irritate me sometimes! GEEZ!
I have the same fears of flying w/ my kids. I do the same things that you do. Flights really stress me out!
You sound like a good mommy!
Shame on that crabby woman!!! booo, hiss!
July 7, 2009 at 6:56 pm
Ame Dyckman
ARGH! Are you kidding me? That is the rudest thing I’ve ever heard! Kudos to you for engaging MamaTongue in front of the littles, and I hope you all did unflattering impersonations of her when she was out of earshot! (“Look at me, I’m cranky plane lady!) I hope Karma b*tch-slaps some manners into her!
July 7, 2009 at 6:59 pm
Ame Dyckman
Oh, and since we’re sharing good airline stories too, a long time ago on an airplane, I met the actor that played Uncle Jesse from “The Dukes of Hazard.” (Yeah, I know you can’t top that one! Dukes still rules!)
BTW, borry I said “b*tch-slapped” in the previous post. Just got carried away in my outrage on your behalf. Cheers!
July 8, 2009 at 12:21 pm
Marsha Riti
Boo on that rude lady! I am glad you are classy, if it were me I would have lost it.
July 10, 2009 at 3:15 pm
Kevin Michaels
I’ve been on both sidess of that fence – also as a corporate warrior and as a parent and it’s tough. I think that every parent who travels (regardless of whether they are a business geek or not) has to be more understanding of parents traveling with kids and the hardship that airline travel creates on everyone. I remember some times being on particularly brutal trips – filled with angry customers and aggravation at every stop and actually finding a little joy in watching another parent travel with their kids (it brought me closer to my own home and my own kids -if only in my thoughts).
I think you handled an exceedingly nasty traveler in the only way possible short of getting violent or rude.
July 10, 2009 at 5:23 pm
Corey Schwartz
Love the photo. I hate flying with my kids! Last time, we were stuck on the plane for two full hours BEFORE take-off.
July 10, 2009 at 5:57 pm
anitanolan
I would take a bunch of wind-up toys with me. I only pulled them out for trips. I’m sure the people around me loved that, but it kept the kids busy.
July 14, 2009 at 5:24 pm
Kelly H-Y
***GASP**** You are kidding me?!?!?! I cannot believe that woman! Oh my … just unbelievable … you poor thing … you and your family are true and very polite troopers! LOVE the pic by the way!
July 18, 2009 at 12:08 am
Bianca Schulze
I had a similar situation happen to me on a 14hr trip to Australia. It just makes me hope that “karma” truly exists! She’ll get what is coming to her — and kudos to you for biting your tongue, I’m not sure I could have!